BLOG.RALPHKENDRICK.COM

Schoenberg the Romantic?


Arnold Schoenberg.... the mere mention of the name strikes fear into the hearts of the audiences everywhere while conjuring up feelings of admiration among many composers. Though Schoenberg wrote in a variety of styles, he is probably best, if not notoriously, known for the development of the 12-tone system of composing where, in its purest form, each of the twelve chromatic tones are ordered in a specific way and used melodically and harmonically, before the first tone of the twelve is repeated again.

Prior to developing this system, however, Schoenberg continued in and expanded upon the styles of his immediate predecessors in Austria - Wagner, Mahler, Strauss, and Brahms. One of his best-known and most widely performed works is Transfigured Night, an early composition for string sextet/string orchestra, written when Schoenberg was 25.

Transfigured Night is romanticism at its best. Based on a story of love, tragedy and forgiveness, the work includes lush chromaticism; ever increasing waves of harmonic tension and release; and oodles of delicious, soupy violin writing in the extreme upper register.

Interestingly enough, my recording of Transfigured Night is paired with an equally wonderful piece from Schoenberg’s 12-tone period, his Variations for Orchestra. I’ve always been a fan of the Variations, so much so, that even after grad school was over, and no one would have cared, I spent several days one summer analyzing the rows upon which it was constructed.

But earlier this week, I had the good fortune of listening to these pieces back to back and, though they were constructed with completely different methods, I was struck by the similarities between the works. In fact, I heard some nearly identical melodic gestures in the strings that seemed to be imbued with the same romantic underpinnings and yearnings for something beyond this world. It made me begin wonder, was Schoenberg a romantic all along?

Listen to the excerpts below.  In both cases, I've placed similar melodic gestures from both works back to back.  In both examples, the sample from Transfigured Night precedes the sample from Variations for Orchestra.


isn’t the same sense of drama, and romantic spirit present in both?  Both works share similarities in their usage and treatment of half step melodic resolutions and  in general, I get the same sense of sturm und drang in both.  The difference between the two, is in the harmonic and textural content, where the Variations seems busier and much less settled harmonically.  

 
The fact that Schoenberg returned to tonality in the latter stages of his life is often overlooked by music criticism. In the thirties and forties, he completed the Suite in G for strings, the 2nd Chamber Symphony, and a Theme and Variations for Band, all works based on tonality.

Of course, historians like figures that can be categorized into nice and neat boxes, so Schoenberg is often cast as part of the Second Viennese or twelve tone school. And, while this is a true categorization, it also ignores some of the important works he completed before and after his purely dodecaphonic period.

Composing takes a lot of time, and at the end of our life, when we sense that at any given point, we could be composing our last work, we only have time to write in the styles we truly believe in.  The time for exploring is essentially over and the rush to make final musical arguments is on. 

Doesn’t the fact that Schoenberg returned to tonality for some of his later works illustrate that he never truly disavowed tonality as a viable and equally effective compositional system to dodecaphony? Otherwise, why return to it at the final stage, when time is running out?

Is it possible, he was a romantic all along?

ShareThis

Are Composers Hermits?

As many of you know, I have a day job in the insurance business.  I'm officially called a Relationship Manager, which involves quite a bit of gregariousness.   It's important for me to develop good relationships with my customers, so they'll trust me, and honestly share what they really think.  So, often, I'll turn a two minute phone conversation into a fifteen minute one, asking them about their families or other things they may be passionate about.  Over time, we become friends.

I genuinely like developing relationships with people all over the country, but by nature, I'm not a 'chatty kathy'...
<< MORE >>

Crunching the Numbers

One year ago today, I published the first version of www.ralphkendrick.com. I knew that having a website was important in terms of marketing, but I didn’t really know what to expect in terms of traffic and what level of interest the site would generate. I remember thinking at one point, if I receive 2,000 visits to the home page in the first year I’ll consider that a victory.

The first year results are in, and they are beyond my wildest expectations. I thought I’d share them with you as a ... << MORE >>

The Ripple Effect

A few days ago, I had lunch with a family who was interested in having their son take composition lessons with me. His current teacher, who is also a friend of mine, will soon be going off to graduate school in another city.

During the lunch, I took some time to review a few of the young composer’s pieces. It was apparent that he was talented and had received some quality instruction.

“It’s pretty easy to find a piano teacher, but how did you go about finding a composition teacher?” I ... << MORE >>

Fifteen Reasons for Optimism

Today I’m celebrating 13 years of working in the business world. I suppose I’m sort of an oddity, as far as composers go. Many teach at a University, or have day jobs much more closely associated with music or the arts. Me? Well, I work in IT for an insurance company.

While it would certainly be enjoyable to teach at a University, I’m thankful for the perspective and skills I've gained in the business world. Today, I thought I’d provide some off-the-cuff musings on some of the benefits, perspective, and learning experiences my time outside of the music industry has afforded me.
... << MORE >>

ReAssessing Musical Value

Each year, the Iowa Choral Directors Association teams up with the Iowa Composers Forum to award a $1,000 commission to a composer for writing a new work for varied levels of choirs. In year 1, for example, the commission is awarded for a work for church choir, year 2 the work might be for a collegiate-level choir, in year 3 the work might be for an elementary-level choir, etc.

I’m very embarrassed to admit this, but I remember asking myself at one point, “Why are we awarding the same commission amount to someone for writing a piece for an elementary-level school choir?"... << MORE >>

Avoiding Cliches, the New Cliche

One of the things I enjoyed about my composition studies with Martin Jenni, was how openly he shared his music with me and the comments he made as we listened through the various sections of his pieces.  During one of my lessons, as we listened to an early orchestra work of his, he said, "I allowed myself a harp glissando in this section."  I found that to be a very interesting comment, and it was one of those things that stuck with me, and grew in meaning as I became a more 'seasoned composer'.

Another encounter, ...
<< MORE >>

Is the CD DOA?

It's a very exciting time for my professional composing career, as a few weeks ago, I received copies of a new CD featuring a professionally recorded performance of my solo clarinet work, Three Turns of the Wind.  Clarence Padilla, a clarinetist with the Des Moines Symphony and a Professor of Music at Drake College, recorded the work and included it on his CD titled With the Wind.

As I removed the first CD from its wrapper, I enjoyed looking at how professionally it was packaged, with fancy printing on a green insert, and a picture of a ... << MORE >>

Something to Write Home About

When I write grant applications for the Iowa Composers Forum, I spend a lot of time making the argument that arts events greatly enrich a community’s quality of life.

There are studies showing that the symptoms of dementia and Alzheimer’s are greatly diminished in certain nursing home patients for several days after they visit an art exhibit. Research has also shown that positive experiences help reduce stress, our perception of pain, and can even help the body heal. I argue that music concerts provide a temporary, and much needed balm for those suffering from chronic physical ... << MORE >>

Much Ado About Doing Nothing

My Grandpa Kendrick used to say, "The wishbone is a lot stonger than the backbone." Isn't that a timeless nugget of wisdom? It's so much easier to complain and to wish "things weren't the way they were" then to actually do something to change things for the better.

I was reminded of Grandpa this weekend, reading a blog lamenting the state new music finds itself in. The author was very clear at identifying the problems, and also did a great job "wishing those problems didn't exist." 

Frankly, I've just grown tired of this ... << MORE >>

Monthly Archives

Category Archives

Recent Entries

  1. Schoenberg the Romantic?
    Thursday, August 26, 2010
  2. Are Composers Hermits?
    Friday, August 20, 2010
  3. Crunching the Numbers
    Friday, August 13, 2010
  4. The Ripple Effect
    Tuesday, August 10, 2010
  5. Fifteen Reasons for Optimism
    Tuesday, August 03, 2010
  6. ReAssessing Musical Value
    Thursday, July 29, 2010
  7. Avoiding Cliches, the New Cliche
    Thursday, July 22, 2010
  8. Is the CD DOA?
    Monday, July 12, 2010
  9. Something to Write Home About
    Tuesday, July 06, 2010
  10. Much Ado About Doing Nothing
    Monday, June 28, 2010

Recent Comments

  1. Ralph on Schoenberg the Romantic?
    9/2/2010
  2. Brad Fowler on Schoenberg the Romantic?
    9/2/2010
  3. Ralph on Schoenberg the Romantic?
    8/28/2010
  4. Brad Fowler on Schoenberg the Romantic?
    8/28/2010
  5. Ralph on Living Composers 14, Dead Composers 0
    8/27/2010
  6. Tacfit Commando on Living Composers 14, Dead Composers 0
    8/27/2010
  7. Hugo Blisiya on Much Ado About Doing Nothing
    8/21/2010
  8. Ralph on Avoiding Cliches, the New Cliche
    7/25/2010
  9. Denise Knaack on Avoiding Cliches, the New Cliche
    7/25/2010
  10. Ralph on Avoiding Cliches, the New Cliche
    7/23/2010

Subscribe


Blog Software